Asana vs ClickUp vs Monday vs Productive Reviewed (2024)
Asana, ClickUp, and Monday are popular project management software solutions.
These tools provide essential project and task management features, which include the ability to customize your workspace, create tasks, and collaborate more efficiently. However, each solution has some special quirks that can make it more or less suitable for business owners.
You can also consider a fourth alternative: Productive. Productive is one of the leading professional services automation tools; it offers a comprehensive feature set tailored specifically to agency operations.
This guide will explore Asana vs ClickUp vs Monday vs Productive to help you find your ideal tool. We’ll review individual benefits and downsides based on customer reviews. Then, we’ll do a side-by-side comparison of some key features, pricing, and integrations.
Asana vs ClickUp vs Monday vs Productive: Key Takeaways
- Asana is a lightweight tool for project management and workflow automation. It’s suitable for teams with varying levels of software expertise, but it lacks advanced features for business financials, reporting, and invoicing.
- ClickUp is a customizable hub for project and task management. It can be an especially good choice for teams interested in a free solution with limited features. Some main downsides mention issues with platform performance and usability.
- Monday is a work and project management app suitable to various industries, including construction and retail. Reviewers state that it’s simple to use and implement but underline that the free version offers very limited possibilities, especially in comparison to ClickUp.
- Productive is the most robust option. Unlike Asana, ClickUp, or Monday, it offers advanced features for budgeting and financial management. You can forecast key business metrics (such as profitability or revenue) and streamline client invoicing. This is all integrated with project management tools and collaborative features.
Productive Is the Best Business Management Platform
Forecast your agency’s future with an all-in-one tool for project, financial, and resource management.
Asana Overview
Asana provides a streamlined project management space with handy features for remote work and team collaboration.
STREAMLINE TASK MANAGEMENT AND GET PROJECT PROGRESS OVERSIGHT
Key Features
- Asana provides five workspace views, including Gantt, board, list, calendar, and timeline. Users also have private boards to keep easier track of their tasks, as well as an inbox for notifications. There are project and task templates, and custom fields can be added to a company-wide library as customization options.
- Asana also includes some basic reporting and capacity planning features. For reporting, you can use Asana’s templates and set up reporting dashboards. Resource management offers a workload chart for visualizing availability and scheduling employees.
- Additional task management and collaboration features include integrated time tracking with an embedded timer and manual entry. Asana also provides workflow automations and goal setting and tracking.
Pros
Users usually enjoy Asana for its ease of use and simplicity:
Asana is pretty easy to navigate and minimalistic in design, while ClickUp is way more complex and it is perfect for people who are highly, overly organized.
Source: Reddit
It can be an especially good choice as a starter tool in businesses with straightforward projects and smaller teams to manage. You can also check out our comparison of Asana vs Trello or Asana vs Wrike to find how it squares up to other traditional project management tools.
Cons
Although Asana has essential features for project planning, some users believe that it’s a more limited solution overall:
Fewer automations than some of the other tech platforms on the market. It feels like some of the other platforms like ClickUp & Monday are updating their functionalities at a faster pace and Asana is falling behind a bit.
Source: G2
Other reviews mention that although the software has a free option available, some comparable solutions offer more features in their basic plans: “I believe price was a real incentive to go with ClickUp too, it was much better value for money compared to Asana” (paraphrased from Capterra).
Additionally, consider that some important features are lacking, including project budgeting and financial forecasting. Asana alternatives like Productive gather more of your data, which results in more robust reports.
ClickUp Overview
ClickUp is a work management software with a wide range of features tailored to companies of all shapes and sizes.
USE PRE-MADE TEMPLATES FOR CALENDAR VIEWS AND OTHER WORKSPACE STYLES
Key Features
- For collaboration features, ClickUp offers multiple project views, as well as agile project management features that include sprint management and Kanban boards. You can also create your documentation within the platform, use templates for tasks, docs, and more, and automate workflows.
- Build private dashboards by combining various widgets. You can add various reports, such as deadlines and tasks completed, tracked and estimated time, sprint burndown or velocity charts, and more.
- ClickUp’s time management lets you record time from desktop, mobile, and web browser. You can add time retroactively and filter your entries by day, week, month, etc., from your time sheets. ClickUp also features a workload view for visualizing and managing capacity.
Pros
Users often mention that they enjoy ClickUp for its customization and flexibility:
Due to a rich collection of features, ClickUp is very flexible thus a great app for the personal productivity system of a power user.
Source: Capterra
An additional benefit compared to some other ClickUp alternatives includes capabilities specialized for development companies, such as sprint management, a GitHub integration, and various reporting charts — though alternatives such as Jira might still be a better pick for a specialized web development tool.
Cons
By far, the most frequently mentioned downside of ClickUp is its performance. Multiple users mention issues with slow loading times, crashes, and bugs of varying severity and frequency.
There’s a new version of ClickUp called ClickUp 3.0 that toutes additional features, usability, and performance improvements; however, users mention that many of the issues still remain:
The improvement points for ClickUp are still related to performance, as even after the update to version 3.0, I still encounter issues and instabilities.
Source: G2
Additionally, users have mixed opinions on this new version — some find it more user-friendly, and others prefer ClickUp as it was before. The rollout is still in progress, and certain reviews mention that they have been waiting for it for a long time. Like Asana, ClickUp lacks native budgeting and invoicing capabilities, which is something to keep in mind.
You can also check out our ClickUp vs Wrike comparison to learn more.
Monday Overview
Monday Work OS is a work management platform for businesses in professional services, construction, manufacturing, media, and retail industries.
MANAGE PROJECT STATUS UPDATES WITH PORTFOLIO FEATURES
Key features
- Monday.com includes more than ten views for visualizing your tasks and projects, including Gantt and Kanban boards. It also provides real-time dashboards that can be customized with various widgets, as well as no-code automations.
- For task management, project managers can use monday.com to assign ownership and set deadlines, task dependencies, to-dos, and manage file sharing. There’s an integrated timer, so you can compare planned vs actual project progress.
- You can also schedule and allocate resources and get an overview of your ongoing projects for informed decision-making and enhanced multiple-project management.
Pros
Compared to other common project management tools, as well as the specific ones from this list, monday.com is usually reviewed as the most visually appealing and user-friendly choice:
I’ve already had a chance to experience several team/project management tools but monday.com offers a slightly more straightforward dashboard rather than ClickUp or Asana has. So without spending too much time learning how to use the platform, you can easily find yourself connected with it.
Source: G2
It can be a good pick for businesses that need a range of handy features, including time tracking, task management, and automation features, but don’t require complex capabilities for business process management. For businesses seeking a versatile solution with time tracking, task management, and automation features but without the need for complex business process management capabilities, explore the comparison between Trello vs Monday vs Productive.
Cons
According to user reviews, monday.com is not the most flexible project management software solution, though it’s more customizable than Asana: “Monday was not as robust in its customization of workflows as ClickUp” (Source: Capterra).
Additionally, monday.com also lacks some core features for business management compared to more robust project management software tools. For example, you can’t link time tracking to specific clients, which limits reporting capabilities. There’s also no native option for project budgeting or client invoicing.
You can check out some top cost management tools to learn why efficient budgeting is so important for business success.
Productive Overview
Productive is an all-in-one solution designed for professional services agencies, with advanced features such as financial management, resource scheduling, and forecasting.
handle the simplest to the most complex projects with productive
Key Features
- Productive’s project and task management include strong customizability, with various project views (including Kanban and Gantt chart view), custom task fields, notification management, and flexible permissions. You can also build automations, track billable vs non-billable time, and create documents from scratch (now with Productive AI!).
- Productive has a wealth of features for financial management. You can: define your budgets, manage employee cost rates, streamline revenue recognition, forecast profit margins, and create invoices from the platform.
- For resource management, you can create a responsive schedule that takes into account your employee’s working hours, holidays, and time off. You can also manage and forecast utilization across various metrics (per individual, department, seniority, and more).
- Productive offers extra features, such as a lightweight sales CRM for improved client communication and sales metrics management and a Reporting feature with various templates, visualizations, and custom fields for agency-specific parameters.
Pros
The best part of Productive is that you can get so many functionalities in one platform. Not only does this help you save on costs, but it also makes workflows more efficient and standardizes data across the entire organization.
We used to have a project management tool, a time tracking tool, a support tool, a way we handled opportunities and sales-driven processes. Those were all separate tools that we had, and it wasn’t good. It also meant that all that data was being lost every time we switched between tools, or we had to find a way to normalize the data between them. And now, the fact that it’s all in one, it’s really a game changer.
Get first-hand insights into how Productive can help you switch from multiple tools to a single all-in-one solution.
The financial management and forecasting features are another key selling point. Monitoring your budgets in real-time across multiple clients is crucial to making the right decision for your financial health, and Productive lets you do just that.
Cons
Productive is the most advanced solution compared to the alternatives and competitors in this list. In general, this means that the learning curve is more steep. However, business owners who invest their time in Productive will find a scalable solution with features that can support their company’s future.
Productive Is the Best Business Management Platform
Forecast your agency’s future with an all-in-one tool for project, financial, and resource management.
Differences in Asana, ClickUp, Monday, and Productive
We’ll compare these popular tools according to their main target industry, core features, ease of use and customer service, integration capabilities, and pricing:
Industry-Specific Needs
Monday, ClickUp, and Asana can all be used across various industries. ClickUp has some specific features for development companies with agile workflows, though all three solutions support views such as Kanban, backlog management, and various productivity and project progress reports.
Productive is the only agency-specific tool on this list, as it’s designed to support workflows for engineering teams, marketing teams, creatives, consultancies, and more.
Usability and Learning Curve
Among these solutions, ClickUp is the most poorly rated for its usability and steep learning curve. Multiple users report that the platform can be challenging to learn, the user interface can be confusing, and there are plenty of performance issues, even with the recent platform overhaul.
In comparison, despite its complexity, users usually find Productive fairly easy to use and onboard to:
The tool is really intuitive. We got used to it fairly quickly and didn’t really experience any major bumps in the road.
Asana and monday.com are evenly matched. Some users find monday.com easier to use, while others mention that it requires a lot of workarounds and learning to get it functioning.
Monday is only as good as the administrator and system put in place. It doesn’t work if you’re users are not trained and if there’s not a proper system in place. It takes work to put it together, but I believe that once a system is implemented and users are trained and required to use it, it’s a great tool to have.
Source: Paraphrased from Reddit
Project Management and Collaboration
All four solutions have features that support task and project visualizations, with customizable views, task dependencies, to-dos, and other associated features. There are some slight differences, but your choice will mostly come down to preference and personal working style.
However, there are some more notable differences in collaboration features. For example, Asana and Monday don’t offer document collaboration and document editing tools, while Productive and ClickUp do.
Productive’s docs help you handle all of your information in one place
However, consider that ClickUp’s native docs come with some caveats: “At this point, it’s more efficient to use Google Docs because that doesn’t crash every 10 minutes” (Source: Capterra).
Despite this, all of these options can be excellent tools for project management, task progress tracking, and workflow automation.
Productive has given the team a lot more autonomy. Before, in Asana, it was much more a developer working on a ticket and handing it back to a project manager, and not so much focused on accountability. I’m very keen on agile processes and I think Productive helps us be more accountable by reassigning tasks to different team members. Now our developers have more autonomy in their involvement in projects.
Reporting & Analytics
Productive has the most extensive features for business reporting and analytics. It pulls data from so many different sources, including your employee information and cost rate, billable hours tracked, sales performance, resource scheduling, project budgets, and more.
A particularly powerful feature includes financial forecasting, which means that you can reliably predict your business performance across specific metrics. For example, you can check what happens to your budgets and profit margins if you add more teammates to a project. This promotes proactive decision-making and helps ensure maximum profitability and efficiency.
PRODUCTIVE PROCESSES LARGE AMOUNTS OF PROJECT DATA IN REAL TIME
Though ClickUp is not as robust regarding financial data, users might find the sprint and agile-specific reports to be a handy feature.
Overall Features
Productive is the most robust software solution on this list. It not only offers features to support the entire project lifecycle, but also your broader business operations. This includes extensive financial management and invoicing, resourcing, and in-depth business intelligence.
Though Monday, ClickUp, and Asana all have resourcing features to some extent, Productive takes this to another level:
Scheduling was a real pain with Monday and Productive made things so much easier, especially since Gantt charts were released. Being able to allocate time per task was a big deal for me since I could finally see how much time each person is spending on a project and how much capacity we have.
Additionally, features such as project accounting and budgeting are built into Productive, while other tools only provide this through third-party tools (or not at all).
Integrations
- Asana offers a large range of integrations. The most popular ones include Google’s suite (Google Drive, Google Docs, Google Calendar), development and design software such as Figma and GitHub, and HubSpot and Mailchimp for marketing workflow tools. However, the accounting integrations are somewhat limited.
- ClickUp offers a variety of integrations with other project management apps, collaboration, and marketing and agency CRMs. This includes GitHub, Slack, Google Calendar, Figma, Hubspot, and Zapier. Like Asana, ClickUp lacks accounting integrations.
- Monday integrates with communications, marketing, and financial tools. This includes QuickBooks for accounting, the Google product suite for documentation and communication, and Miro for brainstorming and collaboration.
- Productive offers a limited number of native integrations for now, but they cover the main financial, HR, collaboration, and communication needs. This includes Slack, Google Calendar, Jira, HubSpot, QuickBooks, Xero, BambooHR, and more.
Pricing
- Asana offers a free version of the platform for up to 10 team members, with unlimited tasks and unlimited projects, though some key features aren’t included, such as time tracking, workload charts, and advanced reporting. It also offers two paid plans (Starter and Advanced) and two custom enterprise plans.
- ClickUp also provides a free plan with unlimited tasks and team members, though this excludes native time tracking, workload management, and advanced automations. There are two paid plans (Unlimited and Business Plan) and a custom enterprise paid plan.
- Monday offers a restricted free plan for up to two seats and three boards, which is best for individuals. There are three paid plans (Basic, Standard, and Pro) and an enterprise plan with advanced automations and permissions.
- Productive doesn’t offer a free plan, but you can check out a 14-day free trial before subscribing. It has two fixed subscription plans and two customizable plans for larger teams and enterprises (learn more about Pricing).
Finding Your Best Management Platform
Asana, Monday, ClickUp, and Productive are all good project management platform options for businesses. If you’re looking for a free tool with limited features, ClickUp might be your best choice.
For a user-friendly interface and streamlined implementation, consider monday.com or Asana. Both are beginner tools with essential collaboration features and lightweight additional capabilities.
If you want to manage your entire agency processes from a single platform, you can consider Productive. The tool offers integrated financial, project, and resource management features with advanced reporting capabilities.
Book a demo with Productive to support your agency’s future with an all-in-one management solution.
Connect With Agency Peers
Access agency-related Slack channels, exchange business insights, and join in on members-only live sessions.
