Top 7 Scenario Planning Software in 2026 (Prices + Ratings)

Lucija Bakić

Last updated Nov 3, 2026

The best scenario planning software are Productive, Runn, Adaptive from Workday, Anaplan, Pigment, Vena, and Microsoft Excel. We picked these seven tools for how they let you change and compare scenarios.

For every tool, you get its key scenario features, pros and cons, pricing, rating, and who should skip it. A comparison table, a four-step selection process, and a fixed-fee staffing example help you choose between them.

What Are the Best Scenario Planning Tools in 2026?

In 2026, the best scenario planning tools are Productive, Runn, Adaptive from Workday, Anaplan, Pigment, Vena, and Microsoft Excel. Productive is the best scenario planning software for agencies and consultancies that price and staff client projects.

Jump to a tool:

At a glance comparison table (prices and ratings checked November 2, 2026)

ToolWhat you changeWhat you seePrice of the plan you need (US dollars)Rating out of 5 (G2 unless noted)
ProductiveLine items, rates and people on a deal or budgetRevenue, cost, profit and marginUltimate plan, custom quote4.6
RunnWhich tentative projects are switched onCapacity and utilization, with project margins in reportsStandard plan, $11 per resource seat a month (20-seat minimum)4.8 (Capterra)
Adaptive from WorkdayDrivers in personal or shared what-ifsBudgets and forecasts across linked plansCustom quote, 30-day free trial4.3
AnaplanAssumptions in finance, sales or supply chain modelsOutcomes compared across finance, sales and supply chainCustom quote4.6
PigmentAssumptions in native what-if versionsScenarios of one plan, compared in real timeCustom quote, 14-day free trial4.6
VenaAssumptions in Excel-based modelsBest, worst or custom cases across departmentsProfessional or Complete package, custom quote4.5
Microsoft ExcelUp to 32 values at a timeFormula results for each value set in one reportMicrosoft 365 Apps for business, $10 per user a month, paid yearly4.7

How We Chose This Shortlist

We only kept tested scenario planning software that shows what you can change in a scenario. We checked every price and rating on November 2, 2026.

We drew pros and cons from G2 and Capterra reviews, and Productive comes first because it offers a true all-in-one approach.

1. Productive – Best for Services Firms Modeling Staffing and Margin

Productive runs projects, resource planning, budgets and billing for agencies and consultancies as one professional services automation (PSA) platform. Its Scenario Builder models several versions of one deal or budget and shows each one’s profit margin.

Try Productive’s scenario planning

See How a Staffing Change Moves Your Margin

A staffing swap changes your margin, and you often see the change only after hours are logged. A scenario lists your services (the types of work you sell, such as design or development).

You assign people to each one, and Productive’s Scenario Builder recalculates profit and margin. You can model scenarios for each staffing mix and choose one before the proposal goes out.

Compare Pricing Options Without Copying the Budget

Each pricing option for a client usually means another copy of the budget spreadsheet to keep in step. You build each option as a scenario on the same deal, adding services by hand or from rate cards.

Compare them, then apply the most profitable one to the budget, replacing its services or adding to them.

We wanted something that could give us a real-time overview of our whole business and serve as a single source of truth. We needed an integrated system that would handle everything from daily task management to high-level forecasting. While exploring options, we came across Productive, and I was immediately drawn to its clean, intuitive interface.

Ross Francis,
Creative Director at Present Works

Plan Staff for Deals You Haven’t Signed Yet

A deal you expect to win needs people, but nobody books them before it’s signed. Tentative bookings let you plan resources on unconfirmed deals and budgets without counting the hours as scheduled.

A screenshot of Productive’s Resource Planner, scenario planning software showing each person’s project bookings, daily hours and time off


Book people based on your pipeline of upcoming work.

Productive’s Resource Planner shows them as a gray overlay on capacity, so you see clashes before the deal closes. For hires you haven’t made yet, you can book a placeholder instead of a named person.

Pros

  • Profitability shows up per client. Team costs and overheads are broken down for each client, so you can see which accounts make money.
  • Budgets, tracked hours and plans connect per client. You set a budget for each client, track hours against it and plan future campaigns from the same numbers.

Cons

  • Capacity terms take time to learn. Capacity, available, scheduled and worked hours are separate figures, and they’re easy to mix up at first.
  • Proposal design has limits. If you want full brand styling or your own HTML template, the proposal layout options may feel narrow.

Who Should Skip Productive?

Skip Productive as your scenario planning software if your team won’t log time or schedule bookings. Budget figures in Productive come from both, so the margin you modeled can’t be checked against actual work.

Pricing

  • Plans start with the Essential plan at $10 per user per month, which includes essential features such as budgeting, project & task management, docs, time tracking, expense management, reporting, and time off management.
  • The Professional plan includes custom fields, recurring budgets, advanced reports, billable time approvals, and much more for $25 per user per month.
  • The Ultimate plan has everything that the Essential plan and Professional plan offer, along with the HubSpot integration, advanced forecasting, advanced custom fields, overhead calculations, and more. Book a demo or reach out to our team for the monthly price per user.

The Scenario Builder comes with the Ultimate plan. G2 rating: 4.6 out of 5 (checked November 2, 2026).

Know a Staffing Change’s Margin Before You Commit

Productive applies a chosen scenario to the deal or budget, so nobody retypes the numbers.

Book a demo

2. Runn – Best for Resource Managers Testing Tentative Projects Against Capacity

Runn is a resource planning tool that schedules people across projects and tracks their capacity and utilization. You save tentative projects (unconfirmed work) as a scenario, then switch each one off to see how capacity changes.

Key Features

  • Saved private scenarios
  • Tentative project toggles
  • Capacity impact in Charts and Reports
  • Duplicate versions of one project
A screenshot of Runn’s scenario planning software showing team capacity against confirmed and tentative workload by week


Source: Runn

Pros

  • Setup takes little time. Team capacity is visible soon after you start.
  • Hours and dollars are tracked together. Each staffing change shows its effect on project spend.

Cons

  • Long timelines take extra scrolling. Planning months ahead means moving back and forth a lot.
  • Planner colors follow phase, not client. Spotting one client’s projects in the plan takes longer.

Pricing and Capterra Rating

Saved scenarios start on the Standard plan at $11 per resource seat a month, with a 20-seat minimum. Standard allows three saved scenarios per user, and Advanced, a custom quote, has no limit. Capterra rating: 4.8 out of 5 (checked November 2, 2026).

Who Should Skip Runn?

Teams that test many versions of a single deal should skip Runn. Each version is another project copy, and you delete the losing ones once the deal is decided.

3. Adaptive from Workday – Best for Finance Teams That Plan Department by Department

Adaptive from Workday, formerly Workday Adaptive Planning, gives finance teams a financial scenario planning tool for budgets and forecasts. You build your own what-if scenarios in a private sandbox, then share the best ones with your team.

Key Features

  • Personal and shareable what-ifs
  • Compare multiple scenarios
  • Driver-based forecasting
  • Linked plans
A screenshot of Adaptive from Workday’s scenario planning software showing an operational analysis dashboard with P&L by quarter


Source: Adaptive from Workday

Pros

  • Budget and workforce plans are easy to compare. Creating a version and checking its outcome is quick.
  • Models keep a version history. Changes to a forecast stay traceable from one planning cycle to the next.
  • Non-finance staff can add their numbers. The input screens feel familiar to people outside finance.

Cons

  • Custom formulas have a steep learning curve. So does the admin work behind more advanced models.
  • Initial setup can need vendor help. Expect some back-and-forth before your first model is ready.

Pricing and G2 Rating

Pricing is a custom quote, and Workday offers a 30-day free trial. G2 rating: 4.3 out of 5 (checked November 2, 2026).

Who Should Skip Adaptive from Workday?

If you plan who works on which client project, Adaptive from Workday is the wrong choice. Its workforce plans cover headcount and hiring timing, which leaves project staffing to a second tool.

4. Anaplan – Best for Enterprises Linking Finance, Sales, and Supply Chain Plans

Anaplan connects finance, sales, supply chain and workforce plans on one platform for scenario planning and analysis. Its Integrated Business Planning app models scenarios in real time across your plans.

Key Features

  • Anaplan AI scenario analysis
  • Impact simulations for supply chain planning
  • Sales scenario comparisons
  • Anaplan CoModeler
A screenshot of Anaplan’s scenario planning software showing a cost center dashboard with budget variances and an opex summary


Source: Anaplan

Pros

  • Complex business logic stays transparent. Its calculation engine handles detailed rules across a model.
  • Input changes show their impact at once. Contributors can change their inputs without a model rebuild.

Cons

  • Licenses and upkeep cost a lot. Keeping models running also takes paid expertise.
  • Dimensions are hard to change after setup. Reworking hierarchies later runs into limits.

Pricing and G2 Rating

Anaplan doesn’t publish prices, so you’ll need a custom quote. G2 rating: 4.6 out of 5 (checked November 2, 2026).

Who Should Skip Anaplan?

Anaplan is hard to justify for planning teams with nobody trained to build and maintain its models. Because adding a scenario changes the model’s structure, it waits until someone learns model building.

5. Pigment – Best for Finance Teams Comparing What-If Versions Without Copying the Plan

Pigment brings planning, forecasting and reporting into one AI planning platform for business and technical teams. Scenario planning is native, so you test what-if versions in a few clicks instead of starting new plans.

Key Features

  • Native scenarios for what-if
  • Create, compare and refine scenarios
  • Real-time scenario runs
  • Dynamic modeling
A screenshot of Pigment’s scenario planning software showing an executive summary dashboard filtered to the base case scenario


Source: Pigment

Pros

  • Totals drill down to detail with ease. Finance leads can reach the figures behind any number.
  • Plans can be cut across many dimensions. One model answers questions by region, product or any other dimension.

Cons

  • Report layouts take extra effort. Frames, its newer layout builder, is still maturing.
  • Training videos are limited. Advanced models take practice to build.

Pricing and G2 Rating

Pigment publishes no prices, though a 14-day free trial lets you test it before asking for a quote. G2 rating: 4.6 out of 5 (checked November 2, 2026).

Who Should Skip Pigment?

You’ll want a simpler tool than Pigment if many budget owners each need different access to the plan. That setup is the hardest part to get right, with access rights stacked in several layers.

6. Vena – Best for Finance Teams That Want to Keep Excel as the Interface

Vena adds a centralized database, workflows and templates to a native Excel interface for financial and operational planning. Its scenario models show how changes to revenue or expenses would move your cash flow.

Key Features

  • Cross-department what-if analysis
  • Scenario planning templates
  • Driver-based models
  • AI scenario modeling
A screenshot of Vena’s scenario planning software showing an Excel profit and loss statement with a what-if forecast column


Source: Vena

Pros

  • It looks and works like Excel. If you know Excel, it’s quick to learn.
  • Actuals and budget share one view. Variances show without switching reports.
  • Data from many systems is kept in one place. Every plan draws on the same consolidated numbers.

Cons

  • New data can be slow to load. Uploads can drag during month-end close.
  • Saving templates takes extra steps. Files must be saved first, then moved to the right location.

Pricing and G2 Rating

Vena Solutions sells Vena in two packages, Professional and Complete, and prices both on request. G2 rating: 4.5 out of 5 (checked November 2, 2026).

Who Should Skip Vena?

For teams that don’t use Excel every day, Vena is a poor buy. Staff who rarely open Excel get its learning curve without the head start that Excel habits give.

7. Microsoft Excel – Best for One-Off What-If Models on a Small Budget

Microsoft Excel includes what-if analysis tools in its desktop spreadsheet app for testing a financial model. A scenario is a saved set of values Excel swaps into your cells, while Data Tables handle sensitivity analysis.

Key Features

  • Scenario Manager
  • Goal Seek
  • Data Tables
  • Solver add-in


Source: Microsoft Excel

Pros

  • Formulas can model almost anything. Any logic a decision needs can be written as a formula.
  • Detailed models run in the workbook itself. One-off models need no separate system.
  • Nearly everyone already knows it. Clients and partners can open your model without new software.
  • Pivot tables are a standout. Outcomes roll up by client, month or scenario.

Cons

  • Hard-coded numbers cause formula errors. One typed-in value or wrong format can break a calculation.
  • Version history is hard to keep straight. Shared desktop files can end up with conflicts and overwrites.

Pricing and G2 Rating

Desktop Excel comes with Microsoft 365 Apps for business at $10 per user a month, paid yearly. G2 rating: 4.7 out of 5 (checked November 2, 2026).

Who Should Skip Microsoft Excel?

Once more than one person edits the model, skip Microsoft Excel for scenario planning. Collecting everyone’s input means one workbook per person, then a manual merge into one file.

How to Choose a Scenario Planning Tool

Since these tools model different decisions, choose a scenario planning tool by testing it on the decisions you make. That takes four steps: list your decisions, list their inputs, rebuild one in a trial, and count setup hours.

Step 1: Write Down the Three Decisions You Model Most

From last quarter’s proposals, list the three decisions you argued over most, like a fixed-fee price or staffing mix. Next to each, write the deciding number and the value that changes your answer, like a 40% margin floor.

If a decision has no deciding number yet, set one before you look at any tool.

Step 2: List the Inputs Each Decision Needs

List each decision’s inputs, such as bill rates, cost rates, booked hours and each deal’s win probability. Note each input’s source system, and fail any tool that makes you retype inputs that change every week.

Teams whose hours and budgets aren’t tracked anywhere yet are better off picking project management software first.

Step 3: Rebuild Last Quarter’s Biggest Decision in a Trial

Load your biggest decision’s real numbers into a trial, and build a base case and a downside. If a vendor only offers demos, ask for one built on these numbers.

In the downside, raise hours 15%, then check that margin updates everywhere without manual edits. The tool fails if the base case doesn’t match your planning spreadsheet or the downside means copying the plan.

Step 4: Count the Setup Hours Before You Sign

Ask each scenario planning software vendor for a written setup plan with an owner and an hour count. Weigh those hours against last month’s spreadsheet rebuild hours times 12.

Then ask how a chosen scenario reaches your live budget. If the plan needs an outside consultant and there’s no planning budget for one, cross the tool off.

Turn the Winning Scenario Into Your Live Budget

Productive applies a chosen scenario to the deal or budget, so nobody retypes the numbers.

Book a demo

Scenario Planning Example: Staffing a Fixed-Fee Project

This scenario planning example works through one of those decisions: staffing a web agency’s $60,000 fixed-fee build. Scenario A uses one senior developer, and scenario B uses two mid-level developers who need 60 more hours.

Example: two staffing scenarios for a $60,000 fixed fee

Example figuresA: one senior developerB: two mid-level developers
Hours300 senior360 mid-level, plus 40 senior review
Cost rate$90 an hour$50 an hour mid-level, $90 an hour senior
Labor cost$27,000$21,600
Margin55%64%

What can you conclude?

  • Scenario B has the higher of the two profit margins: 64% against 55%, or $5,400 more profit. The catch is 40 hours of senior review, so reserve them in resource planning before the build starts.
  • Scenario B frees 260 senior hours, and in the best-case scenario the senior bills them on another project.
  • Scenario A is the better call when your mid-level resources are booked or the build is hard to delegate.

If that keeps happening, plan hiring against booked demand before the next fixed-fee pitch.

What Is a Scenario Planning Tool?

A scenario planning tool is software that builds scenarios of a plan from different assumptions and compares their numbers. You’ll also see these solutions sold as scenario modeling software, scenario simulation software or what if scenario analysis software.

Financial forecasting predicts the likeliest outcome, while scenario planning software sets alternatives side by side. If one best estimate is enough for your planning, see how dedicated forecasting tools compare.

For services firms, the planning inputs with the most uncertainty are bill rates, staffing mix and pipeline deals. Because a fixed fee can’t move, testing those inputs before you sign is risk management built into planning.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Many Scenarios Should You Compare?

Compare three scenarios for each decision: a base case, an upside and a downside. Add a fourth when a single deal or hire decides the outcome on its own.

How Often Should You Update a Scenario Plan?

Update a scenario when an input changes, like a deal closing, a new rate card or someone leaving. Then review all future scenarios in the planning session where you update a budget forecast each month.

Is Scenario Planning Worth It for a Small Team?

Scenario planning is worth it for a small team that sells fixed fees or decides on hires. One wrong staffing call shows up in margin, and what-if scenario planning software lets you check it early.

Final Thoughts: One Platform for the Plan and the Numbers

A planning scenario is only as current as the rates, bookings and budgets behind it. When your tools for scenario planning are separate from those numbers, each new version means copying data first.

In Productive, scenarios use your existing services and actual expenses, and one click applies the winner.

If you want to check a staffing change against margin first, book a demo of Productive’s scenario planning software.

Connect With Agency Peers

Access agency-related Slack channels, exchange business insights, and join in on members-only live sessions.

Lucija Bakić

Product Marketing Specialist